CH#6: Rum Punch Cupcakes

February 24, 2008 at 5:40 pm | Posted in cupcakes, events, sweet things | 18 Comments

rum punch cupcakes

If you ask me, any time involving rum punch is a good time.  It may have been a decade (or more!) since spring break in Cancún, but rum punch is just as much fun today as it was back then.  For this month’s liquor-laden Cupcake Hero event (hosted, as always by Laurie, and this time with the assistance of Tempered Woman), I wanted to make a cupcake that, while maybe didn’t have quite the same GGW effect (totally kidding–that is not me at all!!) as knocking back a few plastic cups o’ rum punch, at least incorporated some the flavors.  Pineapple, orange, and of course rum, were what I was going for.  And please don’t forget the paper umbrella…

To start off, I made some modifications to Billy Reece’s Vanilla, Vanilla Cupcake recipe, which I used in my cherry-lime rickey cupcakes awhile back.  By modifications, I mean I dropped the vanilla, vanilla and made them rum, rum.  I swapped out all of the vanilla extract and one-quarter of the milk for Caribbean rum.  They did have a different texture than Billy’s original recipe.  Not dry at all, but more dense…almost like a rummy poundcake.  I’m guessing this is because when I substituted 25% of the milk for rum, I took out a portion of the fat component.  I didn’t expect that to happen, but I didn’t entirely mind it either.

rum punch cupcakes

I wanted to make a filling for the cupcakes, but didn’t want to do a lot of work.  I decided to spruce up some more of that Bird’s custard powder I have in the cupboard (any custard mix would do and homemade would be great) with orange zest and Grand Marnier.  I set aside a portion of the cooled orange custard and mixed crushed pineapple into the rest.  (I bough a fresh pineapple and roughly crushed up a good sized chunk of it in my mini food processor.)  Filling done.

Coming up with a frosting was a tricky one.  Meringue didn’t sound right…too sweet and not enough flavor.  And buttercream was too heavy and fussy.  I really liked the whipped cream topping on my cappuccino cupcakes last month.  It was super easy and light, but also needed a bit of tropical flavor.  I took that plain orange custard I had set aside before and folded that into whipped cream, and my frosting was ready to go.  Since whipped cream is not the most stable stuff in the world, I’d recommend doing this part shortly before serving.

These were quite nice; pleasantly boozy but not too overpowering.  And I love anything with a little umbrella!

rum punch cupcakes

You may notice that the recipe below is rather vague in measurements (quite bogan as they say in Australia).  This is because I quartered the cupcake recipe (this gave me four cupcakes, but I could have squeaked out five if I’d made them a bit smaller), and then I basically eyeballed what I’d need to fill and frost them, since there were so few.  I trust that you have good judgement, and if you make too much of something, then consider it an extra snack.

Rum Punch Cupcakes makes as many as you want

-Start with a batch of baked and cooled Billy’s Vanilla, Vanilla Cupcakes, substitute rum for all of the vanilla in the recipe and up to 25% of the milk.  (Not wanting 30 cupcakes, I did a quarter batch, which yields four or five.)

-Make and cool some rum simple syrup.  See here for the recipe for plain simple syrup.  To flavor it, add a splash of rum as soon as you take it off the heat.  (You can make a full recipe of plain syrup and just flavor a portion with rum.  The rest can be saved in the fridge for a month or so and be used to sweeten iced tea or coffee, or to moisten other cakes, etc.)

-Make and chill some orange custard, using your favorite pudding recipe with orange zest and Grand Marnier added to taste, or prepare custard powder according to package instructions, flavoring with orange zest and Grand Marnier.  Set aside about 1/4 of it for filling and the rest for topping.

-Into the filling portion of the custard, stir in some drained crushed pineapple.  This will probably be a couple of spoonfuls, depending on how many cupcakes you are making.  You can used canned crushed pineapple or roughly crush some fresh pineapple in the food processor.

-To fill the cupcakes, use a small knife or round cookie cutter to cut a plug out of the center of each (going in from the top).  Save the top bit of each plug.  Spoon a small amount (about 1/4 teaspoon) of rum simple syrup into each cavity.  This is just to keep the cakes moist…don’t drown them.  Fill each cavity with pineapple-orange custard.  Cover with the top bit so the filling is not exposed.

-Make the frosting from lightly sweetened whipped cream folded together with the reserved plain orange custard (about equal parts).  You can whip it up a bit more if it is not stiff enough to sit nicely on top.

-Top and decorate as you see fit.


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. i am in awe of your creativity.

    give me cupcakes in the kitchen over cocktails at the beach any day. 🙂

  2. Cute cupcakes! How fun! I tried to make my CH the other day and just wasn’t satisfied, we will see if I try again. These just scream summer to me! Yeah!

  3. oh my gosh the pics are so darn cute~ as always. The last one is pure art with the dancing umbrellas. I’m such a sucker for the unbrealls! I totally anticipate seeing these guys poolside 😉
    Great cupcake entry, perfect timing making me long for poolside with the snowoutside…

  4. These look amazing! This brought me back to my honeymoon a year and a half ago. We went to St. Lucia and literally had rum punch with our breakfast, lunch and dinner!

  5. I just wanted to tell you how much I love reading your blog and have named it E for Excellent!

    I must try this recipe…the cupcakes look amazing!!!

  6. That looks like such a fun (and delicious) cupcake. It really makes me look forward to my trip to the Bahamas in May!

  7. Hi Steph

    They look fabulous!!! I have tagged you for a meme. Go to and please ignore if you have already been tagged


  8. I have to say, the umbrellas are pure genius – these are adorable! And I love your idea for the pineapple custard filling ^__^. I’m going to keep this recipe in mind for summer…

  9. one of these, a frothy drink, and a cabana boy…and I am a happy camper…:)

  10. These are so reminiscent of holidays in Cancun with friends. They are very cute and tropical! 🙂

  11. Forget the cabana boy, a dishwasher boy would be better! Those are some of the cutest cupcakes I’ve ever seen!

  12. So coooool!!!! I love it.

  13. Alcohol and cupcakes. Perfect combination. Make me wanna go to the beach.

  14. i love rum punch! great job with the challenge!

  15. I am not a cupcake fan, but with these, I can be converted. They are soooo cute.

  16. Your cupcake has been chosen for ATC’s Weekly Cupcake Collection! Click the link to see more. Looking forward to your next cupcake creation!

  17. YUM!! man this was so the best Cupcake Hero lol

  18. you see! I wanted to use a pretty little umbrella for my pina colada cupcakes. Yours look SO pretty. Very festive. And I found that the alcohol cupcakes initially seem VERY dense. I had to remake my island passion cupcakes a few times in order to make them a little fluffier. Bet yours were just dern delicious! Oh! and the frosting debate was eternal for them, I bet. You seemed to have gone through a lot of the same thought process as I did.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at
Entries and comments feeds.

%d bloggers like this: